Medico e Bambino
2007
Novembre 2007
numero 9
AGGIORNAMENTO




Il vaccino contro il papillomavirus umano: efficacia dichiarata ed efficacia dimostrata

SIMONA DI MARIO1, MARCELLO BERGAMINI2, DANIELA SPETTOLI1, VITTORIO BASEVI1, NICOLA MAGRINI1
1Centro di Documentazione sulla Salute Perinatale e Riproduttiva - SaPeRiDoc - Centro per la valutazione dell’efficacia dell’assistenza sanitaria, CeVEAS, Azienda USL di Modena
2Pediatra di famiglia, Azienda USL di Ferrara

indirizzo per corrispondenza:s.dimario@ausl.mo.it

VACCINE AGAINST HUMAN PAPILLOMAVIRUSES: CLAIMED EFFICACY VERSUS ACTUAL EFFICACY
Key words
Human papillomavirus, Vaccine, Adolescent, Randomised controlled trial, Efficacy

Summary
The recent introduction in the European market of the tetravalent vaccine against Human Papillomavirus raises some concerns on the opportunity to start a national vaccination campaign. In this article an analysis of the currently available evidence, a reflection on what the experts in the field add to the international debate and a comparison between the decision taken in other countries on this issue are presented to guide an informed decision making process on this topic. We searched Pubmed-Medline for RCT on vaccine efficacy. Eight RCT were identified: three studies were related to the bivalent vaccine, and five to the tetravalent vaccine (one describing the Finnish experience of field testing of the tetravalent vaccine efficacy). Flaws related to the presentation of trial results were identified and discussed. The critical analysis of the trials shows that at the moment there is no evidence that implementing a mass vaccination campaign can effectively reduce cervical cancer incidence. Researchers and experts in the field, mirroring the lack of evidence, assume various positions: some of them highlight the theoretical advantage of the vaccine, some of them discuss the limits and information gap still existing and call for more prudence. Moreover, in October 2007, eight out of 27 countries within the European Union took the decision to include the vaccine against Human Papillomavirus in their national immunization campaign. Italian policy makers could consider funding field researches on vaccine efficacy in the Italian context instead of proposing a premature implementation of a mass vaccination campaign.


Vuoi citare questo contributo?
S. Di Mario, M. Bergamini, D. Spettoli, V. Basevi, N. Magrini. IL VACCINO CONTRO IL PAPILLOMAVIRUS UMANO: EFFICACIA DICHIARATA ED EFFICACIA DIMOSTRATA. Medico e Bambino 2007;26:562-571 https://www.medicoebambino.com/?id=0709_562.pdf






L'accesso è riservato agli abbonati alla rivista che si siano registrati.
Per accedere all'articolo in formato full text è necessario inserire username e password.




La riproduzione senza autorizzazione è vietata. Le informazioni di tipo sanitario contenute in questo sito Web sono rivolte a personale medico specializzato e non possono in alcun modo intendersi come riferite al singolo e sostitutive dell'atto medico. Per i casi personali si invita sempre a consultare il proprio medico curante. I contenuti di queste pagine sono soggetti a verifica continua; tuttavia sono sempre possibili errori e/o omissioni. Medico e Bambino non è responsabile degli effetti derivanti dall'uso di queste informazioni.

Unauthorised copies are strictly forbidden. The medical information contained in the present web site is only addressed to specialized medical staff and cannot substitute any medical action. For personal cases we invite to consult one's GP. The contents of the pages are subject to continuous verifications; anyhow mistakes and/or omissions are always possible. Medico e Bambino is not liable for the effects deriving from an improper use of the information.